| Year | Player | Club | Score | Venue |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1937 | J E GENT | Bradford Moor | 150 | |
| 1938 | A FELL | Keighley | 150 | . |
| 1939 | G MARWOOD | West Bowling | 145 | . |
| 1940/45 | NO COMPETITION | |||
| 1946 | A T KYLE | Sand Moor | 153 | . |
| 1947 | A T KYLE | Sand Moor | 149 | . |
| 1948 | J E GENT | Bradford Moor | 142 | . |
| 1949 | A T KYLE | Sand Moor | 147 | . |
| 1950 | A T KYLE | Sand Moor | 148 | . |
| 1951 | G ASH | Beverley | After play-off | |
| 1952 | A T KYLE | Sand Moor | After play-off | |
| 1953 | A SLATER | Wakefield | 155 | . |
| 1954 | A SLATER | Wakefield | 152 | . |
| 1955 | S J BROUGH | Sand Moor | 144 | . |
| 1956 | A SLATER | Wakefield | 145 | . |
| 1957 | E STOKES | Hillsborough | 149 | . |
| 1958 | M LEE | Crosland Heath | 150 | . |
| 1959 | M LEE | Crosland Heath | 145 | . |
| 1960 | P EBORALL | Hillsborough | 146 | . |
| 1961 | A SLATER | Wakefield | 148 | . |
| 1962 | J NEWBOLD | Moortown | 150 | . |
| 1963 | C A CLARK | Ganton | 146 | . |
| 1964 | R FOSTER | Bradford | 145 | . |
| 1965 | IAN SKELLERN | Fulford | 144 | . |
| 1966 | M S HOLLIDAY | Leeds | 143 | . |
| 1967 | M J KELLEY | Ganton | 143 | . |
| 1968 | L P TUPLING | Tankersley Park | 142 | . |
| 1969 | M J KELLEY | Ganton | 136 | . |
| 1970 | S ROLLEY | Phoenix | 147 | . |
| 1971 | L WALKER | Selby | 143 | . |
| 1972 | M J KELLEY | Ganton | 143 | . |
| 1973 | M F FOSTER | Clayton | 141 | . |
| 1974 | J WHITELEY | Pontefract & District | 144 | After play-off |
| 1975 | M J KELLEY | Scarborough North Cliff | 137 | . |
| 1976 | M J KELLEY | Scarborough North Cliff | 146 | . |
| 1977 | R S MITCHELL | Keighley | 142 | . |
| 1978 | M J KELLEY | Scarborough North Cliff | 148 | After play-off |
| 1979 | J R CRAWSHAW | Halifax | 138 | . |
| 1980 | M J KELLEY | Scarborough North Cliff | 139 | . |
| 1981 | M I MACKENZIE | Hillsborough | 147 | After play-off |
| 1982 | C S MONTGOMERIE | Ilkley | 143 | . |
| 1983 | S M BOTTOMLEY | Shipley | 141 | . |
| 1984 | M I MACKENZIE | Hillsborough | 141 | . |
| 1985 | S FIELD | Silkstone | 148 | . |
| 1986 | P HALL | Harrogate | 144 | at Bradford |
| 1987 | P HALL & R M ROPER | Harrogate & Catterick Garrison | 141 | at Fulford joint winners |
| 1988 | C G RAWSON | Brough | 148 | at Moor Allerton |
| 1989 | S EAST | Fulford | 144 | at Alwoodley |
| 1990 | L WALKER | Selby | 141 | at Cleveland |
| 1991 | D DELANEY | Baildon | 143 | at Bradford |
| 1992 | J D DOCKAR | Ganton | 137 | at Headingley |
| 1993 | J D ROBERTS | Howley Hall | 137 | at Hull |
| 1994 | N R LUDWELL | Selby | 141 | at Hornsea |
| 1995 | J N HEPWORTH & N GIBSON | Ilkley & Selby | 142 | at Sand Moor joint winners |
| 1996 | N EMMERSON | Saltburn by the Sea | 141 | at Cleveland |
| 1997 | A WRIGHT | Hornsea | 142 | at Moor Allerton |
| 1998 | M J BUGG & R G HODGKINSON | Selby & Lindrick | 142 | at Hessleÿ joint winners |
| 1999 | S J DYSON | Sand Moor | 137 | at Hallamshire |
| 2000 | G A CLARK & R M HOLLINS | Doncaster & Sand Moor | 138 | at Pannal joint winners |
| 2001 | S COUMBE | Pontefract & District | 137 | at Fulford |
| 2002 | N R SWEET | Moortown | 136 | at Scarcroft |
| 2003 | A J GRAY | Cleveland | 135 | |
| 2004 | J P SAMUEL | Hull | 140 | at Hull |
| 2005 | S BELL | Baildon | 146 | at Huddersfield |
| 2006 | ABANDONED DUE TO BAD WEATHER | |||
