| 1996 | D WOOD & M HARRINGTON | Otley & Sand Moor | 149 | at Headingley Joint winners |
| 1997 | D WOOD | Otley | 152 | at Low Laithes |
| 1998 | A DAVISON & S WILSON | Wakefield & Phoenix | 145 | at Oakdale Joint winners |
| 1999 | M D SKELTON | Hunley Hall | 143 | at Malton & Norton |
| 2000 | C CLARKE | Wath | 141 | at Woodsome Hall |
| 2001 | D DENISON | Howley Hall | 144 | at Knaresborough |
| 2002 | ABANDONED DUE TO BAD WEATHER | |
| 2003 | A HOULDSWORTH & M HEMPSTOCK | Keighley & Doncaster | 107 | at Garforth Joint winners over 27 holes |
| 2004 | N McCARTHY & T HESKETH | Moortown & Oakdale | 148 | at Howley Hall Joint winners |
| 2005 | J MAW | Abbeydale | 144 | at Hessle |
| 2006 | L O'NEILL | Keighley | 138 | at Woodsome Hall |
| 2007 | L O'NEILL | Keighley | 138 | at Sand Moor |
| 2008 | T THORNHILL | Rotherham | 141 | at York |
| 2009 | C K MUFAYA | Pontefract & District | 68 | at Bingley St. Ives over 18 holes |
| 2010 | W WHITEOAK & G WINSTANLEY | Bingley St. Ives & Wheatley | 141 | at Wheatley |
| 2011 | S WILKINSON | Fulford | 137 | at Otley |
| 2012 | A FITZPATRICK & N FELL | Hallamshire & Lees Hall | 147 | at Wetherby |
| 2013 | K LOWE | Wheatley | 141 | at Brough |
| 2014 | T NORTH | Howley Hall | 143 | at The Oaks |
| 2015 | D BRADBURY | Wakefield | 143 | at Doncaster |
| 2016 | M HAY | Hunley Hall | 142 | at Driffield |
| 2017 | I TURNER | Woodsome Hall | 141 | at Shipley |