| 1927 | J W GAUDIN | Alwoodley | 148 | at Ganton | After tie with E L Cheal (York) |
| 1928 | S WINGATE | Leeds Municipal | 145 | at Wakefield | |
| 1929 | H CRAPPER | Harrogate | 145 | at Hull | |
| 1930 | NO COMPETITION | | | | |
| 1931 | O SANDERSON | Bradford | 148 | at Huddersfield | |
| 1932 | ALAN DAILEY | Halifax Bradley Hall | 146 | at Sand Moor | |
| 1933 | ALAN DAILEY | Halifax Bradley Hall | 145 | at Halifax | After tie with J Shanks (Hillsborough) |
| 1934 | J J BUSSON | Pannal | 141 | at Moortown & Sand Moor | |
| 1935 | A LEES | Dore & Totley | 142 | at Dore & Totley & Abbeydale | |
| 1936 | P ALLISS | Leeds Municipal | 138 | at Templenewsam | |
| 1937 | P ALLISS | Leeds Municipal | 140 | at Moortown & Sand Moor | |
| 1938 | H CRAPPER | Harrogate | 145 | at Moortown & Sand Moor | |
| 1939 | A LEES | Dore & Totley | 143 | at Moortown & Sand Moor | |
| 1940/45 | NO COMPETITION | | | | |
| 1946 | A LEES | Dore & Totley | 147 | at Moortown & Sand Moor | |
| 1947 | J FALLON | Huddersfield | 143 | at Moortown & Sand Moor | |
| 1948 | J D HENDERSON | Ilkley | 137 | at Moortown & Sand Moor | |
| 1949 | F JOWLE | Lees Hall | 140 | at Moortown & Sand Moor | |
| 1950 | J SHANKS | Hillsborough | 144 | at Moortown & Sand Moor | |
| 1951 | J FALLON | Huddersfield | 140 | at Moortown & Sand Moor | |
| 1952 | J WADE | Bradford | 145 | at Moortown & Sand Moor | |
| 1953 | B SHELTON | Wheatley | 145 | at Moortown & Sand Moor | |
| 1954 | J FALLON | Huddersfield | 143 | at Moortown & Sand Moor | |
| 1955* | S J BROUGH | Sand Moor | 144 | at Moortown & Sand Moor | |
| 1956 | W LEES | Shipley | 140 | at Moortown & Sand Moor | |
| 1957 | E LARGE | Brough | 143 | at Moortown & Sand Moor | |
| 1958 | J FALLON | Huddersfield | 148 | at Huddersfield | |
| 1959 | G WESTON | Oakdale | 141 | at Moortown | |
| 1960 | B HUTCHINSON | Hallowes | 142 | at Abbeydale | |
| 1961 | C E HUGHES | Woodsome Hall | 145 | at Fulford | After tie with B Hutchinson (Hallowes) |
| 1962 | B HUTCHINSON | Hallowes | 144 | at Sand Moor | |
| 1963 | B HUTCHINSON | Sitwell Park | 143 | at Hull | After tie with B Waites (Saltburn) |
| 1964 | B HUTCHINSON | Moortown | 142 | at Hallamshire | |
| 1965 | H W MUSCROFT | Moor Allerton | 137 | at Pannal | |
| 1966 | B WAITES | Brough | 138 | at Moor Allerton | |
| 1967 | H W MUSCROFT | Moor Allerton | 138 | at Rotherham | |
| 1968 | L PLATTS | Pannal | 137 | at Woodsome Hall | |
| 1969* | M J KELLEY | Ganton | 136 | at Middlesbrough | After tie with R H Emery (Northcliffe) |
| 1970 | S C EVANS | Moor Allerton | 143 | at Bradford | |
| 1971 | G A CAYGILL | Cleckheaton & District | 136 | at Abbeydale | |
| 1972 | B HUTCHINSON | Moortown | 142 | at Fulford | |
| 1973 | R H EMERY | Keighley | 135 | at Ilkley | |
| 1974 | N MELVIN | Sand Moor | 141 | at Sand Moor | |
| 1975* | M J KELLEY | Scarborough North Cliff | 137 | at Hull | |
| 1976 | R HARDCASTLE | Headingley | 144 | at Cleveland | |
| 1977* | R S MITCHELL | Keighley | 142 | at Scarcroft | |
| 1978 | M INGHAM | Cleckheaton & District | 142 | at Rotherham | |
| 1979 | A J BICKERDIKE | Crosland Heath | 134 | at Halifax West End | After tie with H W Muscroft (Roundhay) |
| 1980 | D JAGGER | Selby | 136 | at Ilkley | |
| 1981 | D JAGGER | Selby | 147 | at Abbeydale | After tie with S C Evans (Crosland Heath) *M I MacKenzie (Hillsborough) R Masters (Wakefield) J A Pape (Howley Hall)*J L Plaxton (Fulford) *R M Roper (Catterick Garrison) |
| 1982 | B THOMPSON | Hornsea | 143 | at Wakefield | After tie with D Jagger (Selby) and *C S Montgomerie (Ilkley) |
| 1983 | H W MUSCROFT | Roundhay | 137 | at Huddersfield | |
| 1984 | D JAGGER | Selby | 141 | at Pannal | After tie with *M I MacKenzie (Hillsborough), *S East (York), R Masters (Wakefield) |
| 1985 | D JAGGER | Selby | 138 | at Huddersfield | |
| 2003 | A J GRAY | Cleveland | 135 | at Ilkley | |
| 2004* | J P SAMUEL | Hull | 140 | at Hull | |
| 2005 | J R WELLS | Beverley & East Riding | 142 | at Huddersfield | |
| 2006 | ABANDONED DUE TO BAD WEATHER | | | | |
| *Signifies Amateur | | | | | |