| 1906 | HUDDERSFIELD SECOND | 703 | at Huddersfield |
| 1907 | BRADFORD SECOND | 689 | at Bradford |
| 1908 | SHEFFIELD & DISTRICT | 683 | at Harrogate |
| 1909 | WEST BOWLING | 719 | at Halifax |
| 1910 | ROTHERHAM & DISTRICT | 668 | at Harrogate |
| 1911 | HARROGATE | 670 | at Hallamshire |
| 1912 | ILKLEY | 704 | at Pnnal |
| 1913 | WEST BOWLING | 674 | at Leeds |
| 1914 | ILKLEY | 669 | at York |
| 1915-18 | NO COMPETITION | | |
| 1919 | WEST BOWLING | 708 | at Pannal |
| 1920 | HALIFAX | 689 | at York |
| 1921 | HALIFAX WEST END | 696 | at Moortown |
| 1922 | BRADFORD MOOR | 651 | at Rotherham |
| 1923 | ABBEYDALE | 664 | at Wakefield |
| 1924 | BAILDON | 643 | at Keighley |
| 1925 | MOORTOWN | | at Headingley |
| 1926 | HULL | 648 | at Hull |
| 1927 | BRADFORD | 672 | at Halifax |
| 1928 | KEIGHLEY | 631 | at Fulford |
| 1929 | BRADFORD MOOR | 642 | at Shipley |
| 1930 | KEIGHLEY | 641 | at Hornsea |
| 1931 | HALIFAX | 624 | at Oakdale |
| 1932 | HALLOWES | 651 | at Lindrick after tie with Harrogate |
| 1933 | BRADFORD | 640 | at Bradford |
| 1934 | BRADFORD MOOR | 650 | at Ilkley |
| 1935 | WAKEFIELD | 637 | at Keiighley |
| 1936 | FULFORD | 622 | at Sand Moor |
| 1937 | BRADFORD | 656 | at Brough |
| 1938 | CLEVELAND | 634 | at Garforth |
| 1939 | MOORTOWN | 637 | at Rotherham |
| 1940-45 | NO COMPETITION | | |
| 1946 | HEADINGLEY | 632 | at Scarcroft |
| 1947 | SELBY | 653 | at Fulford |
| 1948 | BROUGH | 679 | at Hallamshire |
| 1949 | HALLOWES | 623 | at Harrogate |
| 1950 | FULFORD | 619 | at Ilkley |
| 1951 | WAKEFIELD | 648 | at Scarborough North Cliff |
| 1952 | GANTON | 639 | at Bradford |
| 1953 | HALLOWES & HILLSBOROUGH | 625 | at Abbeydale - After tie |
| 1954 | CROSLAND HEATH | 623 | at Halifax |
| 1955 | CLEVELAND | 629 | at Cleveland |
| 1956 | SHIPLEY | 657 | at Sand Moor |
| 1957 | HILLSBOROUGH | 626 | at Brough |
| 1958 | WEST BOWLING | 629 | at Shipley |
| 1959 | HALLOWES | 630 | at Rotherham |
| 1960 | BROUGH | 658 | at Wakefield |
| 1961 | BRADFORD | 633 | at Garforth |
| 1962 | DEWSBURY | 621 | at Woodsome Hall |
| 1963 | LINDRICK | 599 | at Harrogate |
| 1964 | FULFORD | 601 | at York |
| 1965 | HEADINGLEY | 613 | at Scarcroft |
| 1966 | WEST BOWLING | 607 | at Hallowes |
| 1967 | HULL | 602 | at Scarborough South Cliff |
| 1968 | TANKERSLEY PARK | 612 | at Leeds |
| 1969 | KEIGHLEY | 601 | at Keighley |
| 1970 | ROTHERHAM | 608 | at Woodsome Hall |
| 1971 | GARFORTH | 620 | at Headingley |
| 1972 | HEADINGLEY | 595 | at Brough |
| 1973 | SCARCROFT | 616 | at Garforth |
| 1974 | SCARBOROUGH NORTH CLIFF | 619 | at Rotherham |
| 1975 | ILKLEY | 645 | at Shipley after tie with Baildon |
| 1976 | ROTHERHAM | 297 | at Leeds - 2nd round abandoned due to bad weather |
| 1977 | SELBY | 615 | at Scarborough North Cliff |
| 1978 | YORK | 595 | at Hallowes |
| 1979 | MIDDLESBROUGH | 607 | at Middlesbrough |
| 1980 | ILKLEY | 608 | at Sand Moor |
| 1981 | SELBY | 609 | at Bradford |
| 1982 | ILKLEY | 589 | at Ilkley |
| 1983 | PONTEFRACT & DISTRICT | 613 | at Hallowes |
| 1984 | SELBY | 625 | at Fulford |
| 1985 | HUDDERSFIELD | 665 | at Crosland Heath |
| 1986 | KEIGHLEY | 616 | at Hornsea |
| 1987 | HULL | 606 | at Shipley |
| 1988 | HALIFAX BRADLEY HALL | 309 | at Sand Moor 1st round abandoned due to bad weather |
| 1989 | HOWLEY HALL | 604 | at Bradford |
| 1990 | SELBY | 591 | at Headingley |
| 1991 | GANTON | 582 | at Rotherham |
| 1992 | HILLSBOROUGH | 589 | at Hallowes |
| 1993 | HULL | 581 | at Middlesbrough |
| 1994 | FULFORD | 574 | at Brough |
| 1995 | FULFORD | 589 | at Abbeydale |
| 1996 | ROTHERHAM | 586 | at Bradford |
| 1997 | MIDDLESBROUGH | 574 | at Middlesbrough |
| 1998 | MOORTOWN | 595 | at Wakefield |
| 1999 | BAILDON | 603 | at Hull |
| 2000 | NORTHCLIFFE | 592 | at Bradford |
| 2001 | MIDDLESBROUGH | 595 | at Teesside |
| 2002 | WIKE RIDGE | 580 | at Middlesbrough |
| 2003 | WATH | 576 | at Rotherham |
| 2004 | KEIGHLEY | 574 | at Keighley |
| 2005 | CLEVELAND | 596 | at The Oaks |
| 2006 | HALLOWES | 586 | at Abbeydale |
| 2007 | SALTBURN BY THE SEA | 581 | at Bradford |
| 2008 | MOOR ALLERTON | 584 | at Moor Allerton |
| 2009 | HESSLE | 586 | at Hessle |
| 2010 | WIKE RIDGE | 283 | at Woodsome Hall - over 18 holes |
| 2011 | RENISHAW PARK | 588 | at Renishaw Park |
| 2012 | FULFORD | 580 | at Keighley |
| 2013 | WATH | 436 | at Hunley Hall - 3 man team started here |
| 2014 | PHOENIX | 450 | at Crosland Heath |
| 2015 | RICHMOND | 439 | at Wakefield |
| 2016 | WAKEFIELD | 452 | at Sand Moor |
| 2017 | FULFORD | 420 | at Wheatley |